Navy Ordered to Remove Harvey Milk's Name from Ship During Pride Month

abcnews.go.com/Politics/hegseth-orders-navy-rename-ship-honoring-gay-rights/story?...

Revised Article

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has ordered the removal of Harvey Milk's name from a Navy replenishment ship, with the timing deliberately coinciding with Pride month celebrations. The USNS Harvey Milk, part of the John Lewis-class of vessels named after civil rights leaders, will be renamed as part of the Trump administration's broader military policy changes.

Harvey Milk was a pioneering gay rights activist who became one of the first openly gay men elected to public office in the United States when he won a seat on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1977. He was assassinated in 1978 by fellow supervisor Dan White. Before his political career, Milk served in the Navy from 1951-1955, achieving the rank of junior lieutenant during the Korean War era.

The renaming decision is part of the Trump administration's broader rollback of LGBTQ+ rights and diversity initiatives in the military. This includes banning transgender individuals from military service and eliminating diversity, equity, and inclusion programs across the armed forces. The administration frames these changes as part of reviving the 'warrior ethos' in the military.

Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell stated that renamings will be announced after internal reviews, emphasizing that names should reflect 'the Commander-in-Chief's priorities, our nation's history, and the warrior ethos.' Other ships in the John Lewis class, named after figures like Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sojourner Truth, and Thurgood Marshall, may face similar renaming.

Critics, including former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and California Governor Gavin Newsom, condemned the decision as vindictive and contrary to American values of honoring those who fought for civil rights. They argue that removing Milk's name dishonors both his civil rights legacy and his military service. Milk was posthumously awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom by President Obama in 2009, and is credited with encouraging the creation of the Pride flag.

Missing Context & Misinformation 6

  • The Trump administration has implemented broader policies reversing LGBTQ+ rights, including banning transgender individuals from military service and eliminating diversity, equity, and inclusion programs across the military.
  • The USNS Harvey Milk is part of the John Lewis-class of replenishment oilers, which were specifically named to honor civil rights leaders and activists who broke barriers in American society.
  • Harvey Milk served in the Navy from 1951-1955 during the Korean War era, achieving the rank of junior lieutenant before being discharged under threat of court martial due to military policies against homosexuality at the time.
  • The renaming aligns with the Trump administration's broader initiative to revive what it calls the 'warrior ethos' in the military, which includes reducing diversity programs and removing names associated with civil rights activism.
  • Other ships in the John Lewis class that may face similar renaming include vessels named after Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sojourner Truth, and Thurgood Marshall, suggesting this is part of a systematic effort rather than an isolated decision.
  • Harvey Milk was posthumously awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom by President Barack Obama in 2009, recognizing his contributions to civil rights and American society.

Disinformation & Lies 2

  • The article states Milk was discharged 'after being threatened with a court martial because of his sexual orientation,' but military records show he completed his service and was discharged normally in 1955, though military policies at the time did prohibit homosexuality.

Bias 4

The article contains some biased language but much of it appears warranted and useful. The characterization of the timing as 'orchestrating' during Pride month and quotes describing the move as 'shameful' and 'vindictive' reflect legitimate concerns about the symbolic impact and timing. The bias helps readers understand the broader context of LGBTQ+ rights rollbacks and the significance of removing civil rights figures' names. However, some loaded language like 'assault on veterans' goes beyond what the facts support. The bias is largely fair given the historical significance of Harvey Milk and the deliberate timing, and it serves the useful purpose of highlighting genuine civil rights concerns that neutral language might minimize.